A because if you follow the story line Arthur is diagnosed with tuberculosis in 1899 and dies 4 years later ending the game with John being the main protagonist, he gets a letter from sadie at pronghorn ranch twice then the 3rd one was killing micah
In 1907. Option A. Several years after the gang's disbandment, Sadie had become a successful bounty hunter. In 1907, she sends a letter to Pronghorn Ranch asking for John to meet her in Valentine. As John walks in the saloon, Sadie is seen bickering with other patrons, and she stabs one in the hand.